After 37 years with State Farm, switched to Progressive a few months ago. Looked at Amica (their reputation has been stellar for years, unfortunately WAY more expensive for me) and others, Progressive wound up being the best deal. Also really like their online tools, insurance card in Apple wallet, and a couple of interactions I've had with them in setting things up went really smoothly.
6-month rates - pretty standard 100/300/100 coverage, zero deductible glass. Jetta is the wife's car.